Richard Lugar on Education

Last Updated : Apr 27, 2012

Summary

Senator Lugar's voting record indicates that he supports voucher systems. He voted in favor of the DC voucher program in 1999 and the creation of a test voucher system in 2001. He also voted in favor of the Education Savings Act and School Excellence Act of 1998, which would have created a tax-sheltered educational savings accounts and in favor of a rules change in 1999 to allow for vouchers and school choice. He voted in favor of the No Child Left Behind program in 2001.

In 2010, Senator Lugar encouraged state representatives to support state legislation to ensure that students were not promoted without learning the required material.

 

Bold Reform Needed

In September of 2009, Senator Lugar released a press statement noting a speech he gave at the Franklin College denoting the need for bold reform.

 

Ending Social Promotion

In February of 2010, Senator Lugar released a press statement noting his belief that social promotion of students should be ended.

 

2012 Campaign Website Statements

 

Voting Record

College Cost Reduction and Access Act

The College Cost Reduction and Access Act is a significant education bill dealing largely with funding for higher education. The bill removes tuition sensitivity for Pell Grants, increases the amount available for Pell grants, Funds the Upward Bound program, establishes the TEACH Grants, reduces student loan repayment rates, sets deferments based on need and establishes some partner based grants. The bill got a great deal of support in the Senate and passed easily. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the College Cost Reduction and Access Act.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the College Cost Reduction and Access Act.

Standards vs Tutors

Again in 2001, the Senate voted on another amendment which would authorize $200 million to provide grants to help states develop assessment systems that describe student achievement. This amendment would replace a previous amendment which would allow parents with children at under-performing schools to use public funding for private tutors. The amendment was widely supported by Democrats, but widely opposed by Republicans. It failed to pass in a 50-47 vote. Richard Lugar voted against the amendment and supported private tutors over creating standards.

Richard Lugar voted against the amendment and supported private tutors over creating standards.

No Child Left Behind Act of 2001

No Child Left Behind was the primary focus of the Bush administration prior to 9/11. The bill requires states to develop assessments in basic skills to be given to all students in certain grades, if those states are to receive federal funding for schools. The Act does not assert a national achievement standard; standards are set by each individual state. The bill got the support of all but 2 Democrats and all but 6 Republicans and passed the Senate in a 91-8 vote. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001.

Amendment - Voucher Program

In June 2001, Senator Gregg introduced an amendment to create a test voucher program for low income students in failing schools. The program would have been in 10 cities and three states. Richard Lugar voted in favor of a voucher program.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of a voucher program.

Teachers vs Tutors

In 2001, the Senate voted on an amendment to the Better Education for Students and Teachers Act which would have provided $2.4 billion in funding in fiscal 2002 for state and local services to hire up to 100,00 additional teachers. This amendment would replace an amendment allowing parents with children at under-performing schools to use public funding for private tutors. Every Democrat that voted supported the amendment, and every Republican that voted opposed the amendment. Richard Lugar voted against the amendment and supported funding for tutors over additional teachers.

Richard Lugar voted against the amendment and supported funding for tutors over additional teachers.

Affordable Education Act of 2000

The Affordable Education Act of 2000 was voted on in early 2000. Among other things, the bill would have allowed tax-free savings accounts of up to $2000 per child annually to be used for public or private school tuition or other education expenses. The bill passed the Senate in a 61-37 vote. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Affordable Education Act of 2000.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Affordable Education Act of 2000.

Rules Waiver

In 1999, the Senate voted on an amendment to the Education Flexibility Partnership Act of 1999 which would have allowed states to waive certain federal rules normally required in order to use federal school aid. A vote in favor of the amendment would have signified support for vouchers and school choice. Every Democrat that voted opposed the amendment, and every Republican that voted supported the amendment. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the amendment and supported school choice.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the amendment and supported school choice.

Education Savings and School Excellence Act of 1998

This 1998 legislation would have allowed people to take money from their IRAs to pay for qualified elementary and secondary education expenses, including home schooling expenses. It increased the annual contribution limit from $500 to $2,000. It permits corporations to contribute to education IRAs. Although the bill passed in the Senate easily, it was vetoed by the President. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Education Savings and School Excellence Act of 1998.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Education Savings and School Excellence Act of 1998.

Education Savings Act and School Excellence Act of 1998

In 1998, the Education Savings Act for Public and Private Schools Education Savings and School Excellence Act of 1998 attempted to create tax-sheltered educational savings accounts. Although the bill got a majority of the votes, it did not get the numbers needed and failed to pass with the support of most Republicans, but the opposition of most Democrats. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Education Savings Act and School Excellence Act of 1998.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the Education Savings Act and School Excellence Act of 1998.

Amendment - Vouchers in DC

In 1999, the Senate voted on an amendment to the DC appropriations bill that would have installed a voucher system to allow students to choose to attend a private school, or any school other than their assigned public school. The measure failed to get the votes it needed with most Republicans supporting it and most Democrats voting in opposition to it. Richard Lugar voted in favor of the DC voucher system.

Richard Lugar voted in favor of the DC voucher system.

 

Sponsored and Cosponsored Legislation

Session-110; Bill Number-S 761; America COMPETES Act - Cosponsor

A bill to invest in innovation and education to improve the competitiveness of the United States in the global economy.

Session-106; Bill Number-S 1487; Excellence in Economic Education Act of 1999 - Cosponsor

Amends the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA) to establish a program for excellence in economic education under title X (Programs of National Significance).

User Comments